⚡Speed News by Kbuzzy.com

ADOR disputes reporting on NewJeans contracts, explains youth protections, contractual penalties and AI use conditions

On November 5, ADOR issued a response disputing The New York Times’ reporting on NewJeans’ exclusive contracts, explaining youth protection provisions, the contract negotiation process, the calculation of contractual penalties and conditions for the use of AI content.

ADOR disputes reporting on NewJeans contracts, explains youth protections, contractual penalties and AI use conditions
File photo · TVTEN · NewJeans 230905.png · CC BY 3.0 · License

ADOR said HYBE’s labels enter into supplementary youth protection agreements with trainees, guaranteeing personality rights and the rights to sleep, education and rest until they reach adulthood. It maintained that NewJeans’ exclusive contracts also contain basic human rights protection provisions covering these matters.

Regarding the contracting process, ADOR explained that a draft was shared on January 7, 2022, and the contracts were signed in April of that year following questions and answers, email exchanges and review by lawyers representing the artists. It added that HYBE’s legal team provides a basic template, while the label and the artists’ representatives determine key terms, including how payments are calculated and settled. It also claimed that HYBE’s legal team proposed ways to reduce the costs borne by the members, but ADOR’s then-deputy CEO rejected them.

ADOR maintained that although contractual penalties are calculated using average monthly revenue over the period in which revenue was actually generated, the financial outcome is the same as under the standard contract because NewJeans has continuously generated revenue since its debut. It said the provision applies only when an artist unilaterally terminates the contract, or breaches material terms with the aim of terminating it, while the company is fulfilling its obligations. It also explained that the same formula as in the standard contract was applied in the litigation involving Danielle, and that the Seoul High Court had found no issue with the provision.

ADOR said AI content using the members’ faces and voices requires each artist’s consent. In response to concerns about a provision allowing the use of names, likenesses and voices even after the contracts end, it explained that it has no plans to use the artists’ intellectual property at its own discretion in violation of the law.

ADOR said CCTV cameras are installed only in shared spaces such as practice rooms, and that it respects the wishes of the individuals concerned and their parents regarding education. It claimed that provisions prohibiting defamation and preventing unhealthy romantic relationships with the opposite sex are also necessary to protect the artists and had received parental consent. HYBE denied ever forcing the members to discontinue their studies or requiring or encouraging them to undergo plastic surgery against their wishes.

ADOR emphasized that then-CEO Min Hee-jin, the deputy CEO, the members and their parents, and legal representatives for some members participated in coordinating the contract wording and the final signing. It said it had explained these details to The New York Times with supporting materials and requested their inclusion in the article, but they were not reflected.

What does a supplementary youth protection agreement contain? The standard supplementary agreement established by the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism provides rights protection guidelines appended to the contracts of young singers, actors and trainees. It specifies efforts to guarantee freedom of choice, the right to learn, personality rights and the right to sleep, and prohibits assault, coercion and threats. It also allows contracts to be terminated in cases of violence, sexual violence or abuse by entertainment business operators or their executives or employees. These are the contents of the standard document and are distinct from whether the individual contracts described by ADOR have been fulfilled.

Sources